GvilleTX

Text size

Reading size
Light or dark

Ask GvilleTX

Back to News
GvilleTX ReportingLocal News

City backs park-and-walk plan over Denton Street closure, releases records on 2025 permit

Police approved the neighborhood association's Halloween plan with no road closures. The City says petition organizer Martin Phillips filed a 2025 closure permit in the group's name without its approval, and Phillips disputes it.

The City of Gainesville is backing a neighborhood association's Halloween plan that keeps South Denton Street open to cars, and it has released records on a 2025 street-closure permit that it says Martin Phillips filed in the association's name without the group's approval. Phillips started the petition that asks the City to close part of Denton Street during trick-or-treating on Oct. 31.

In a statement dated Oct. 7 and posted to its Facebook page Oct. 8, the City said the Gainesville Police Department approved the Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Association's 2026 Park and Walk permit on Oct. 7. The approved plan closes no roads. Families park in designated areas and walk into the neighborhood. The City said that cuts car traffic while residents and emergency crews keep their access.

City of Gainesville statement on the Halloween 2026 street closure

The two-page statement is dated Oct. 7, 2026. The City posted it to Facebook on Oct. 8 with the records below.

City of Gainesville

Original document
  1. Page 1 of the City of Gainesville statement on the Halloween 2026 street closure
  2. Page 2 of the City of Gainesville statement on the Halloween 2026 street closure

The statement says City records show Phillips submitted a 2025 street-closure permit that presented him as acting for the association, and that association officials later told the City he had no authorization to make that request. The City rescinded the permit and refunded his payment, according to the statement. The Facebook post that carried the statement went further. In it, the City said it is "hesitant to work with him as he falsified his application last year."

The City wrote that KXII-TV had called for comment on Phillips's campaign. It said it gave the station's reporter the documents, a statement and an interview with the City Manager, and that it released the same documents to the public with personal information blacked out. The release includes no response from Phillips.

View on facebook
The City of Gainesville's Oct. 8 post, with its statement and the released records.

Phillips answers the City

After the City's release, Phillips wrote on Facebook that the City's statement about him was inaccurate. He said he has text messages and documents that support his account of the 2025 application, and other witnesses who can back it up. "This isn't just about me," he wrote. "It's about transparency, accountability, and whether residents can volunteer their time to address a public safety concern without finding themselves publicly accused of wrongdoing."

Phillips said more than 550 people have supported the effort. He wrote that Gainesville needs "a fundamental change in leadership" and that he will remind voters in May how the City handled the issue.

His post shared a comment from Pam Clegg, a neighbor. Clegg wrote that she was at the association meeting where members approved Phillips and other volunteers, her mother among them, to lead the association's Fall Event Committee. She wrote that Phillips was representing the association when he filed the 2025 application, that association leaders went around their own committee to stop the closure, and that she left the association over it.

Clegg also questioned the City's description of the 2025 Park and Walk as a success. She asked what the City measured, and she asked it to explain why it accused Phillips publicly and what keeps it from closing the street for a few hours on one night. "The goal here is to protect children," she wrote.

Her account differs from the association's Sept. 24, 2025, letter, which says the committee assigned to the event was not part of the decision to obtain the permit. The released records do not include the association's meeting minutes.

What the 2025 records show

The police department received Phillips's handwritten Application for Parade or Public Assembly on Aug. 27, 2025. It asked to close Denton Street from East Main Street to Hird Street, and Church Street from Dodson Street to Dixon Street, from 5 to 9:30 p.m. on Friday, Oct. 31, 2025. He estimated about 1,200 people. Where the form asks for the organization's responsible heads, it names a person, whose name the City redacted, as chair of the association's fall event committee, and Phillips as vice-chair. Question 12 asks anyone applying for another person or group to attach that party's written authorization. The answer written there is "N/A."

Phillips also wrote that he had discussed the idea with Mayor Tommy Moore, City Manager Barry Sullivan and the police chief, and that "all indicated support for the concept." He expected to need 12 to 15 barricades from the City, with volunteers at each intersection.

Martin Phillips's 2025 application to close Denton Street

Received by the Gainesville Police Department on Aug. 27, 2025. Red notes on the form say they were made after a conversation with Phillips. The City blacked out addresses, phone numbers, signatures and the committee chair's name.

City of Gainesville, released Oct. 8, 2026

Original document
  1. Page 1 of the 2025 parade and public assembly application, listing Martin Phillips and the requested Denton Street closure
  2. Page 2 of the application, with hours of 5 to 9:30 p.m. and question 12 answered N/A
  3. Page 3 of the application, with barricade needs and the date received, Aug. 27, 2025

A police department email on Sept. 11, 2025, sent City staff the signed permit for the "Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Assoc – Trick or Treating" event. A City check requisition shows a $570 barricade fee was paid on Sept. 17.

On Sept. 24, the association's co-presidents, Shirley Warner and Janice Ross, wrote to the City's event permit office. Their letter says a permit had been obtained in the association's name, that the committee assigned to the event was not part of that decision, and that the board then voted that the association could not sponsor the street closure. They asked the City to take the association's name off the permit. The letter says the group had no money set aside for security or event insurance, and that a recent hotel-tax grant was committed to new district street signs and a walking-tour app. Any future event, it says, would need a written plan from a full committee and the approval of residents and members.

The association's Sept. 24, 2025, letter to the City

The City stamped it received on Sept. 25, 2025.

Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Association, via the City of Gainesville

Original document
  1. Letter from the Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Association asking that its name be removed from the event permit

The police department told City staff on Oct. 2, 2025, that the permit had been rescinded. On Oct. 8, the department requested a $570 check to Phillips to return the barricade fee. The released records do not include the 2025 permit itself.

The rescinded permit and the refund

The Oct. 2, 2025, notice that the permit was rescinded, and the Oct. 8 check requisition returning the barricade fee.

Gainesville Police Department, via the City of Gainesville

Original document
  1. Police department email of Oct. 2, 2025, saying the trick-or-treating permit was rescinded
  2. City check requisition of Oct. 8, 2025, refunding a 570 dollar barricade fee to Martin Phillips

The plan for this year

Warner and Ross wrote to Sullivan, Moore, Police Chief Kevin Phillips and other City officials on Aug. 10, 2026. Their letter says the association would hold its Park and Walk again on Saturday, Oct. 31. It promises wider publicity and a map that marks parking lots and walking routes into the neighborhood, and it asks police to help again with patrols and with traffic and parking.

The permit the police chief signed on Oct. 7 lists "NO Road Closures." Parking lots open at 5 p.m., and visitors walk into the neighborhood from there. The association's map names 11 lots, from City Hall at 200 S. Rusk St. on the north end to Gainesville Junior High at 1201 S. Lindsay St. and the junior high track on Hird Street to the south. It marks walking routes down Dixon, Rusk, Denton and Lindsay streets.

This year's Park and Walk: the letter, the permit and the map

The association's Aug. 10, 2026, letter, the permit the police chief approved on Oct. 7, 2026, and the association's parking and walking map.

Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Association and Gainesville Police Department, via the City of Gainesville

Original document
  1. Letter from the Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Association announcing its 2026 Halloween Park and Walk
  2. City of Gainesville parade or public assembly permit for the 2026 Halloween Park and Walk, listing no road closures, approved Oct. 7, 2026
  3. Park plus Walk plus Treat flyer with a street map of 11 parking lots and walking routes into south Gainesville

Martin Phillips started his current petition on Aug. 19, 2026. It asks the City to close Denton Street between Pecan and Hird streets during the busiest trick-or-treating hours, and it calls the closure a one-evening step that would give children a safer place to walk. It describes hundreds of children and families in the neighborhood each Halloween but gives no count. By Thursday evening it showed 550 verified signatures. Minutes from the Sept. 1 City Council meeting record that he asked the council for a Halloween street closure in the historic district. They show no vote on the request.

The City's statement says every resident may argue for a different approach, but one person's preferred outcome should not be presented as an organization's position without that organization's approval. It says a request to close a public street faces the same test no matter who asks or where the street is. Under Gainesville's parade ordinance, the police chief must weigh traffic, the number of officers an event needs, whether pulling those officers would thin police protection elsewhere in the city, and whether a closure would slow fire or ambulance service. The application fee is $25 and does not come back, and an applicant may also have to pay for extra police protection.

Neighbors split

The City's post drew more than 60 comments by Thursday evening. Many came from parents and residents who want the street closed. Hailey Cooper, who wrote that she has lived on the street for 27 years, said she has had to run into the road on Halloween to keep children from being hit. She expects more children this year because the holiday falls on a Saturday. Brandi Akins wrote that her 13-year-old uses a wheelchair and that cracked sidewalks without ramps pushed them into the street last year. She said the family plans to trick-or-treat somewhere easier this year. Other commenters asked why the City closes streets for parades and Depot Day but not for Halloween.

Morgan Tobias, who wrote that she has hosted public events in Gainesville, said she signed the petition months ago and changed her mind after learning that no organization was running the effort. Event sponsors close streets, she wrote, and they pay for police, barricades, street crews and the liability insurance that names the City. Teresa Harlow Westover suggested that families spread out to the district's side streets instead of crowding Lindsay, Denton and Church.

Why the dark hours matter

The Texas Department of Transportation said in an October 2025 release that pedestrian crashes and deaths in Texas usually peak at this time of year, and that most happen after dark. A study of federal fatal-crash records from 1975 to 2016 compared Halloween evenings with the same hours one week before and one week after. It found pedestrian deaths more than 40 percent higher on Halloween, with a tenfold rise among children ages 4 to 8. The data are national. They do not show whether a closure like the one Phillips proposes, or a park-and-walk plan like the association's, would lower that risk.

43% higher

Pedestrian deaths on Halloween evenings, compared with the same hours one week before and one week after

U.S. fatal-crash records, 1975 to 2016, 5 p.m. to 11:59 p.m. Among children ages 4 to 8, deaths rose tenfold. The data are national and do not test street closures.

Study of federal fatal-crash records, 1975–2016 (PubMed Central)

Nearby Sherman has tried a closure. Council minutes from Nov. 2, 2015, record an organizer thanking the council for closing Travis Street for trick-or-treating. He estimated that about 4,000 people came, far more than the few hundred he had expected.

≈4,000

People at a Travis Street trick-or-treat closure in Sherman, as estimated by its organizer

He had expected 300 to 500. The figure is his own estimate, not an audited count.

City of Sherman council minutes, Nov. 2, 2015

The petition cites the City's Guiding Gainesville 2040 plan, which calls for promoting downtown as a place for entertainment and new festivals. The City's parks and trails master plan lists street fairs at the Farmers Market, with nearby streets closed to cars, as an action for the next one to three years. That item covers the Farmers Market site, not Denton Street.

Other places to trick-or-treat

The City's statement points families to its community events calendar. The ninth annual Scare on the Square runs from 1 to 3 p.m. on Oct. 31, with free activities and trick-or-treating at downtown businesses and the Farmers Market. The Frankie Fright Express runs Oct. 27 to 29 at Leonard Park, with trunk-or-treating from 6 to 8 p.m.

Sources

  • City of Gainesville, statement on the Halloween 2026 street closure, dated Oct. 7, 2026, and the records released with it, posted to the City's Facebook page Oct. 8, 2026: www.facebook.com/CityofGainesvilleTX/posts/pfbid0saFWYWz3ebfkH5Je4MDtiWLr3izWFf79SUVpa72hp85fLNpnX7GUSLwF4iJMqSWwl
  • Gainesville Police Department, Application for Parade or Public Assembly filed by Martin Phillips, received Aug. 27, 2025, released by the City with redactions (same post)
  • Historic South Gainesville Neighborhood Association, letter to the City's event permit office, Sept. 24, 2025, released by the City (same post)

Join the conversation

Keep up with Gainesville